The final choice was the hardest.
I’d already established 4/5th’s of my all-time, under-appreciated Hall of Fame rotation, and had just the one slot left. I considered, and rejected, about half a dozen other pitchers. The one I chose may not come as a surprise to you, but it was a bit of a surprise to me.
But before we move on, allow me to list the other members of my entire under-appreciated HOF roster. Each one is highlighted so you can go back and read each of my prior posts in this series. (Note: Some of the earlier posts in this series featured two players.)
1B Roger Connor
2B Joe Gordon
SS Arky Vaughan
SP Kid Nichols
SP Eddie Plank
SP Dazzy Vance
Not a lot of household names, and that was exactly the point of this series.
So, without further digression, let me introduce to you the final member of my team. You may remember him as Knucksie, usually the best player on lots of bad Braves teams in the 1970’s.
Philip Henry Niekro, of Bridgeport, OH, was better than you might think.
First, let me list the reasons why I wasn’t excited about choosing Niekro in the first place:
1) He never won a Cy Young award.
2) I don’t remember him ever being in the conversation regarding the best pitchers of his era while he was active.
3) He threw a goofy, trick-pitch, the knuckle-ball. Real men throw fastballs, hard sliders and power curves. Niekro was more a horticulturist than a warrior.
4) He led his league in losses four times, losing twenty games in two of those years. Also, his career winning percentage was a mediocre .537.
5) He played for the Braves, one of the most boring teams in mid-to-late ’70’s America.
6) Did I mention he gave up more hits (5,044) than any other pitcher in the 20th century?
So, what’s to like? Well, upon closer examination, there is the impressive career WAR of 91.7, tenth best all-time among pitchers.
Moreover, Phil Niekro is also fourth all-time in innings pitched (5,404), and eleventh in strikeouts (3,342.) In addition, Niekro’s 716 career starts ranks 5th in baseball history.
Niekro also won 318 games in his career while pitching for mostly bad or mediocre teams. He led the N.L. in wins twice, and posted three 20-win seasons and a 19-win campaign as well. His career win total ranks 16th on the all-time list.
Addressing the issue of his lack of Cy Young awards, Niekro was (using WAR as a measurement) the most valuable pitcher in the N.L. in both 1978-79. Yet he finished just sixth in Cy Young voting in each of those two seasons. He did finish as high as second in Cy Young voting in 1969, and he finished 3rd in 1974.
Niekro led his league in ERA once, ERA+ once, strikeouts once, win-loss percentage once, and in complete games, starts, and innings pitched four times each.
Perhaps the best illustration of Niekro’s true value to his team is to compare his own record to the annual win-loss records of his teams.
In his career, over a period of 20 consecutive seasons (1967-86), Niekro posted a win-loss record of 305-255, fifty games over .500. That works out to a .544 winning percentage.
Meanwhile, his teams, over that same period, finished with a cumulative record of 1,552-1,636, 84 more losses than wins, which works out to a .487 winning percentage.
Niekro, then, was .057 percent better than the teams for which he pitched, not an insignificant amount.
Here’s another way to look at it. Let’s break down those 20 seasons by looking at how many times Niekro finished with a record over .500, right at .500, or below .500:
1) Over .500 – 14 times
2) Exactly .500 – 2 times
3) Under .500 – 4 times
Now let’s compare that to what his teams accomplished overall during those same 20 years:
1) Over .500 – 9 times
2) Exactly .500 – 1 time
3) Under .500 – 10 times
So Niekro accumulated five more winning seasons than his teams did, and he posted six fewer seasons with a losing record than did his teams.
Clearly, Niekro’s overall career win-loss mark was hampered to a certain extent by the teams for which he toiled. If he had been lucky enough to pitch for Don Sutton’s Dodgers during that same period of time, it is highly likely that Niekro’s overall career win-loss percentage would have been higher than the .537 mark he ultimately posted.
In fact, if you were to add just one win per season for those twenty seasons, which seems on the low side of fair, he would have finished his career with 338 wins. That total would have placed Niekro just outside of the top ten all-time in career victories, just four behind 19th century star Tim Keefe.
Phil Niekro finally called it quits at age 48 in 1987. A five-time All Star selection, Niekro also won five Gold Gloves in his career. The BBWAA elected Niekro to the Hall of Fame in his fourth year on the ballot, in 1997.
Obviously, then, Phil Niekro was a warrior after all, albeit a quiet one.
And those are the ones whom we should hold in the highest regard.
Regardless of whether you agree with my choices for my all-time under-appreciated HOF team, I hope you have enjoyed this series. I have already begun work on my next series, which I will launch next week.
Once again, thank you for reading.
- The Hall of Fame’s Most Under-Appreciated Players: Part 1 (ondeckcircle.wordpress.com)
- The Hall of Fame’s Most Under-Appreciated Players: Part 2 (ondeckcircle.wordpress.com)
- The Hall of Fame’s Most Under-Appreciated Players: Part 3 (ondeckcircle.wordpress.com)
- The Hall of Fame’s Most Under-Appreciated Players: Part 4 (ondeckcircle.wordpress.com)
- The Hall of Fame’s Most Under-Appreciated Players: Part 5 (ondeckcircle.wordpress.com)
- The Hall of Fame’s Most Under-Appreciated Players: Part 6 (ondeckcircle.wordpress.com)
- The Hall of Fame’s Most Under-Appreciated Players: Part 7 (ondeckcircle.wordpress.com)
- The Hall of Fame’s Most Under-Appreciated Players: Part 8 (ondeckcircle.wordpress.com)
- Phil Niekro makes his pitch for R.A. Dickey (knoxnews.com)
- 30th anniversary: Phil Niekro’s great clutch game (hardballtimes.com)