The On Deck Circle

Baseball History, Commentary and Analysis

Baseball’s Surprising Stats: Ted Williams

Ted Williams is commonly considered the greatest hitter in baseball history.

He was the last batter to hit over .400 (.406 in 1941, at age 22), and he won the Triple Crown twice in his career.  No modern player has won the Triple Crown even once since Carl Yastrzemski did it in 1967.

English: An image of Major League Baseball hal...

English: An image of Major League Baseball hall of famer Ted Williams. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

Williams was an uncommonly patient hitter who hit a lot of home runs and drew a lot of bases on balls.  Unlike the mythical portrayal of “Casey at the Bat,” a superlative slugger who wasn’t afraid to strike out, Williams actually didn’t strike out very often.  In other words, he did not sacrifice batting average for power.

If you peruse Williams’ career numbers over at (as indispensable a baseball reference tool as exists anywhere), you’ll find lots of “black ink” on his resume, indicating that he led his league in multiple offensive categories several times throughout his fabled career.

There are batting crowns, home run titles, and, for the modern sabermetrics-inclined baseball fan, OPS+ and WAR victories as well.

But did Ted Williams, the greatest hitter of all-time, ever lead his league in hits?  

To clarify, I’ve already pointed out that Williams won several batting titles.  But was there a single season during which he actually accumulated the most safe hits in his league?

Among players who have won batting titles, several of them have also led their league in hits.  Tony Gwynn, for example, won eight batting crowns and also led his league in base hits seven times.

Ty Cobb won an amazing 11 batting titles and led the league in base hits eight times.  Rogers Hornsby won seven hitting crowns and led the league in hits four times.

Generally speaking, then, players who win multiple batting crowns also tend to  lead their league in actual hits at least some of the time.

It may surprise you to learn, then, that Ted Williams never once led his league in hits.

Ted Williams’ career high for hits in a season was 194 in 1949, when he was 30-years old.  Interestingly, despite winning six batting titles in his career, Williams did not lead the league in hitting in the season in which he accumulated a career high in base hits.

Ted Williams in the Marines

Ted Williams in the Marines (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

The secret to all those batting titles for Ted Williams, was, of course, his fantastic batting eye.  He might not have accumulated a staggering number of hits, but, perhaps more importantly, he generated very few outs per plate appearance, relative to virtually every other hitter who ever played the game.

Ted Williams simply would not swing at a bad pitch.  When he was in the batter’s box, it was the pitcher who was immediately at a disadvantage, despite the fact that the pitcher could throw any pitch he wanted, at any speed he wanted, anywhere he preferred.

What then to make of baseball’s continuing fetish for high hit totals, especially 200-hit seasons?

Just a decade and a half after Williams retired, Dodgers first baseman Steve Garvey, a ten time All-Star and the N.L. MVP award winner in 1974 was widely regarded as one of the best players in the game.  Garvey made a science of accumulating 200 hits in a season, apparently reasoning that it was an obvious mark of excellence.  He reached the 200 hit mark six times in seven years from 1974-80.

Yet Garvey, who never walked more than 50 times in a season, also never won a batting title.  I recall as a boy growing up at the time that a base on balls was considered a wasted plate appearance.  Apparently, there were many players at the professional level who believed the same thing (and some who still do.)  As Juaqin Phoenix’s character, Merrell Hess says in the movie, Signs, “It just felt wrong not to swing.”

There have been many baseball pundits, philosophers, managers, coaches, players and mere fans who have reasoned over the past several decades that to hit for power, you have to sacrifice some batting average.

Sluggers are supposed to drive in runs by driving home runs out of the park.  Meanwhile, the rest of the players — especially at the top of the lineup — like Pete Rose, Lou Brock and Ichiro (none of whom drew very many walks overall)  are supposed to swing away, lashing singles and doubles around the park.

Yet Ted Williams proved long ago that a slugger does not have to sacrifice batting average for power, and that the number of base hits a player accumulates is not really all that important a statistic.

It appears, though, that Ted Williams was just way ahead of his time, and it has taken so-called baseball experts a while to catch up.

But the great ones are always ahead of their time and, as far as hitting is concerned, Ted Williams was the greatest of them all.


Single Post Navigation

13 thoughts on “Baseball’s Surprising Stats: Ted Williams

  1. Keep this going please, grreat job!

  2. Pingback: [ ted williams stats ] Bestest Web Pages | (NetizenOpinion)

  3. There were a lot of guys in Ted’s era who were walk-crazy: Eddie Yost, Eddie Joost, Eddie Stanky, and even some guys not named Eddie.

    • You make a very good point, but few of them also hit with the same kind of power as Ted Williams, drawing tons of walks, a moderate amount of hits, and a sizable number of homers. When Gus Zernial led the A.L. in homers with 33 in ’51, he drew just 63 walks. Roy Sievers had 42 and 76 in ’57.
      Mostly, it interests me, though, that the 200-hit fetish has lingered for as long as it has when it has been clear for a couple of baseball generations now that 200 hits does not guarantee much else in the way of offensive productivity. It’s just a nice round number, and certainly not very easy to obtain, unless you are willing to sacrifice walks, and therefore, probably a certain degree of batting average as well. Ichiro, for example, has reached 200 hits 10 times, but has just two batting titles in part because he has never reached 70 walks in a season in his entire career.
      Frank Thomas comes to mind (along with Barry Bonds, of course) as far as players who were most similar to Ted Williams, combining excellent power, relatively high batting averages, yet never reaching 200 hits in a season due to their high walk totals. Meanwhile, Bonds, Thomas and Williams, three of the greatest hitters who ever lived, all failed to reach the 3,000 hit mark, again because they all drew so many walks. Yet none of them sacrificed any power along the way.
      Thanks for the discussion. This topic interests me very much. Appreciate the comment, and looking forward to your next poem. You’re the best I’ve found on the ‘net these days.
      Best Regards,

  4. Your posts are great fun, Bill, AND I’m always learning from them. And this time, I picked up a new trivia question, too! Thank you for another fine post. I agree with Brad and Mike. Oh! Sorry… forgot to wish you a Happy Father’s Day in time. Best, Michael / Grubby

  5. Agreed, best hitter of them all was the Splendid Splinter, though one hell of a pain in the ass! But long ago he managed my childhood Senators to their best year ever so I’ll never complain about TW. An excellent post, as always. This series has been phenomenal!!


    • Yeah, he was both of those things. Also, a great angler; he loved fly-fishing up in Maine, and used to come into L.L. Bean’s where I worked (though I never got to meet him.) Some guys I know said he used to come in slightly inebriated (or worse) into the fishing department with his long-time fishing / drinking pal, Buddy Leavitt, and hold court long and loud, discussing the finer points of fly-fishing. The man was one of a kind.

  6. Always Wonderful Info, Mr. Bill!
    Very Cool, Indeed!!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: