The On Deck Circle

Baseball History, Commentary and Analysis

Baseball’s Surprising Stats: Roger Maris

This is the fourth installment of my series, “Baseball’s Surprising Stats.”

What is the most famous number in baseball, if not all of sports?

The "M&M Boys," Mickey Mantle (right...

The “M&M Boys,” Mickey Mantle (right) and Roger Maris in the historic 1961 season. Photo from a 1961 issue of Baseball Digest. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

A strong case can be made that 61, the number of home runs Roger Maris hit during the 1961 season when he broke Babe Ruth’s record of 60 set in 1927, would be chosen by many.

It is doubtful that there are many baseball fans who aren’t aware of Roger Maris’ pre-McGwire / Sosa / Bonds record.  (Incidentally, it is often overlooked that Maris’ 61 home runs remains the record for A.L. hitters.)

I have my doubts, though, that very many fans, except Maris’ most adamant Hall of Fame supporters, know exactly how many home runs Maris hit during the totality of his 12-year Major League career, not to mention how many home runs he hit over his seven-year tenure in Yankee pinstripes.

This led me to the primary question I chose to research for this post, “How many home runs did Roger Maris hit during his career?”  I also decided to add an obvious follow-up, “How many home runs did Maris hit as a member of the New York Yankees?”

To begin with, Maris was just 26-years old when he hit his legendary 61 home runs.  Though mentally and physically drained by the ordeal, it wouldn’t have been out of the question that going into his age 27-season, if reasonably healthy, he could have expected to have approached perhaps 50 home runs, (at the very least, 40 home runs), in his follow-up season.

Outfielder Roger Maris during his time with th...

Outfielder Roger Maris during his time with the Cleveland Indians in a 1957 issue of Baseball Digest. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

After all, Ruth was already 32-years old when he slugged 60 homers in ’27, and he followed up that performance by swatting another 54 in 1928.

Maris, however, never reached as many as 40 homers either before or after the ’61 season.  In fact, the 39 home runs that Maris hit in 1960, his first of two consecutive MVP seasons, was the second most home runs he ever hit in one year.

Therefore, his 1962 season, during which he hit 33 home runs, must assuredly have been viewed as a major disappointment by Yankee fans, as well as by Maris himself.

Still, during the three-year period from 1960-62, Maris slugged an impressive 133 home runs.  By contrast, his teammate Mickey Mantle never hit more than 128 over a three-year period, (1956-58.)

But those 133 home runs represent fully 48% of all the homers Maris hit in his career.  Thus, nearly half of his total career value was compiled during just about one-quarter of his actual career.  In fact, as measured by WAR as well, Maris accumulated 17.4 WAR over that three-year stretch, exactly 48% of his 36.2 career WAR.

The answer, then, to my original question, “How many home runs did Roger Maris hit during his career?”  is that Maris hit 275 career home runs, good for 165th all-time, tied with Dean Palmer, Brian Downing, and a recently retired Yankee, Jorge Posada.

As for Maris’ tenure with the Yankees, he hit 203 of his career home runs as a member of the Bronx Bombers.  That total currently ranks 14th on the all-time Yankees home run list, two behind Dave Winfield, and one ahead of Bill Dickey.

Maris’ relatively brief 12-year career was largely defined by one memorable season.  But, Hall of Fame discussions aside, Maris’ legacy will probably outlast those of the vast majority of players in the Hall of Fame, regardless of where he ranks on any particular list of statistics.


Single Post Navigation

10 thoughts on “Baseball’s Surprising Stats: Roger Maris

  1. Pingback: [ roger maris stats ] Bestest Web Pages | (NetizenOpinion)

  2. Bill, just a general comment to tell you I am enjoying every blog post in this series. Thank you for so many enjoyable reads and many new ways to view these terrific players. Warmest Regards from the city by the bay, Michael / Grubby.

    • Michael, Thank you so much for contacting me. I apologize for not getting in touch with you for a while. I’ll be emailing you soon. Hope all is well, and that you completed your 2012 Topps Heritage set.

  3. Nice job, as usual. I still consider Maris’ 61 to be the single season record, not one of the steroid boys’ numbers. Bet most people don’t know Maris won consecutive MVP awards.
    Like the redesign on the site, but having trouble finding a way to comment, which may be a good thing for you 🙂

    • I agree with you as far as the 61 homers are concerned. Glad you like the redesign. I hadn’t even thought about how the comment link would work. Glad you were able to leave one.
      Thanks, Bill

  4. Of all the numbers in baseball, the ones that come to my mind immediately are 61, 56 and 715.

    Sixty-one is the Maris total, of course, and 56 the DiMaggio streak.

    Curiously, I go with 715, the record-breaking homer by Hank Aaron, rather than 714, the Ruth total that was the standard for years. I can’t call to mind what Aaron’s final tally was; 715 is what sticks with me.

    If I were a Cubs fan, I guess I’d add 1908.

    • For me, they’re 61, 56, and 41 (the number on the back of Tom Seaver’s jersey.)

      • Here’s a debate for you–given Clemens’ likely chemical enhancement, is Tom Terrific the greatest pitcher ever?

      • I think a case can be made that Seaver was the greatest, but I also think you can make a case for Walter Johnson, Lefty Grove, and even Pedro Martinez. Depends on which numbers you care to look at.
        I do know, though, that Seaver is my favorite pitcher of all-time, and should be on the short list of greatest pitchers ever.

    • Eric Wilson on said:

      The value of a hitting streak is a complex issue. DiMaggio’s hitting streak was a great accomplishment. He was excellent at making contact with the ball. But surprisingly, walks or lack of them had an effect. Ted Williams, DiMaggio’s rival would never win a hitting streak contest, because he got too many walks. DiMaggio got fewer walks making a hitting streak easier for him than for Ted. Baseball stats experts say that getting walks is a very valuable thing for a hitter to do. It is also ironic that if you swing and miss more, you are likely to get more walks, which Mickey Mantle did.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: