The On Deck Circle

Baseball History, Commentary and Analysis

Best Forgotten Baseball Seasons: Part 25 – The Milwaukee Brewers


Image via Wikipedia

The Milwaukee Brewers:  The Team That Selig Built.

Question:  How does a used car salesman from Milwaukee get to buy his very own pet Major League baseball team?

Answer:  When apparently no one else in North America has the capital to put up front for the purchase.

Some background:  When the Kansas City A’s unceremoniously vacated K.C. for Oakland (it seemed like a good idea at the time) in 1968, a U.S. Senator from Missouri (Stuart Symington) decided to hold hostage baseball’s antitrust exemption, unless Kansas City was  awarded a brand new expansion team, to begin play immediately in the 1969 baseball season.

Thus baseball brought forth four new expansion teams for the ’69 season:  Montreal Expos, San Diego Padres, Seattle Pilots, and Kansas City Royals.

The Seattle Pilots were the sorriest team of the lot, finishing their one and only campaign as a major league franchise (in Seattle) last in their division with a 64-98 record.  If you’ve read Jim Bouton’s classic book, “Ball Four,” you know what a pathetic excuse for a team the Pilot’s were.

Milwaukee, however, had already established itself as a baseball town.  The Braves called Milwaukee home for thirteen seasons (1953-65) during which they never played less than .500 baseball in any single season.  In fact, in the Milwaukee Braves inaugural season, they set a then-baseball attendance record of 1.8 million fans.

(On a side note, Selig, a minority Braves stockholder, had sued the Braves to try to force them to stay in Milwaukee, claiming that a baseball team owes it to their city and to their fans to stay put.  The Braves finally got their wish and moved to Atlanta where they believed attendance would be better.)

Bud Selig got his team, though, and, after just five seasons without a Major League franchise, Milwaukee would once again host a team of its own, beginning in 1970.

It wasn’t pretty.  The 1970 Brewers, née Pilots, finished 65-97, just one game better than their one year in Seattle.

Yet virtually every bad team has at least one bright spot.  And the bright spot on the 1970 Milwaukee Brewers burned surprisingly bright, indeed.

His name was Tommy Harper.

Now, I have to confess that when I started researching this blog-post, I thought I would end up profiling someone like Ben Oglivie in 1980:  41 homers, 118 RBI’s, 333 total bases, Silver Slugger winner, .925 OPS.

Or Sixto Lezcano in 1979:  28 homers, 101 RBI’s, .321 batting average, .987 OPS, Gold Glove.

Or Larry Hisle: Excellent overall campaign in ’78.  Well over 100 RBI’s.  Made the All-Star team.  Finished 3rd in A.L. MVP voting.

Or Cecil Cooper: At least four excellent seasons.  One hell of an underrated ballplayer.  If he had stayed in Boston, he might have been able to have produced Hall of Fame numbers.

But settling on Tommy Harper was a no-brainer.  Here’s why.

Most of the fine Brewers hitters that many of us remember played sometime in the late ’70’s or ’80’s.  I didn’t expect to be able to go so far back in team history and stumble across a player who had one season that overshadowed all the other players.

1970 was Tommy Harper’s Best Forgotten Season:

The previous year, toiling away with the Pilots at age 28, Harper had led the A.L. with 73 stolen bases.  But he had produced a pathetic 21 extra base hits in 537 at bats, including nine homers and just ten doubles!  His .235 batting average and 78 runs scored were also unimpressive.

He did, however, draw 95 walks, and his versatility (he could play 2nd, 3rd or OF) along with his base-stealing abilities, provided some value.

Then something strange happened in his first season in Milwaukee.  Tommy Harper must have sold his soul to the devil at a crossroads in some working-class Milwaukee neighborhood, because overnight and without warning, he became an extremely dangerous hitter.

His final numbers for 1970:

Games: 154

At Bats:  604

Hits:  179

Doubles:  35

Home Runs:  31 (!)

RBI’s:  82

Runs Scored:  104

Batting Average: .296

On-Base Percentage:  .377

Slugging Percentage:  .522 (an increase of .211 points from ’69.)

OPS:  .899 (6th best in league)

OPS+:  146 (6th best in league)

Total Bases:  315 (3rd highest)

Extra Base Hits:  70  (First Place!)

Stolen Bases:  38 (2nd place)

WAR:   7.7 (2nd best in team history)

Power-Speed #:  34.1 (First Place)

In short, in one season he had morphed from Omar Moreno to Bobby Bonds.

Tommy Harper finished sixth in the 1970 MVP voting, and he is still the only 30-30-30 man (doubles, homers, steals) in Brewers history.  In fact, Tommy Harper was the first 30-30 man in American League history.

The 31 home runs Harper hit in 1970 were more than he had hit in the previous four seasons combined.  In fact, they represented 21 percent of all the home runs he would hit in his 15-year career.

But Tommy Harper wasn’t finished playing ball after 1970.  After playing just one more year in Milwaukee, Harper enjoyed three productive years with the Red Sox, scoring over 90 runs twice, and leading the league in stolen bases in 1973 (at age 32,) with 54, breaking the 61-year old Red Sox record of 52 stolen bases previously set by Tris Speaker in 1912.  (Harper’s record has since been broken by Jacoby Ellsbury.)

Tommy Harper finally retired in 1976 at the age of 35.

Why some players suddenly produce one explosive season in an otherwise solid career has always been something of a mystery.  I’m reasonably sure even Tommy Harper didn’t see it coming.

But this is one of the reasons why we love baseball; you can always expect the unexpected.

Single Post Navigation

8 thoughts on “Best Forgotten Baseball Seasons: Part 25 – The Milwaukee Brewers

  1. I was looking for your fearless predictions before this season started when you so accurately felt that this would be the Royals year!!! Congratulations! And as I was looking for that article I stumbled on this one; a topic I’ve been revisiting with more frequency this early off season or almost off season…that of the Brewers not being an expansion team, but rather inheriting the one hit dudders; them Pilots.

    Since you write this article. Braun’s back to back seasons of raking and running 2011 and 2012 out did Harper but there is that thing about Braun. We might throw in Fielder and Yount and even Dave Nilsson with 2 S’s in his name. He put up some impressive numbers for a catcher during some pretty bad years for the Brewers.

    I sort of remember you being surprised to find out that the Braves had a winning record every year they were in Milwaukee and yet here you write that very fact. You must be like me. The memory is going.

    Anyway, I enjoyed this quite a bit and apparently, it’s part 25 of Best Forgotten Baseball Seasons? Well, by George Sisler, I have some reading to do.

    • Hey Steve, Always good to hear from you. To tell you the truth, I’d completely forgotten that I had anything nice to say about the Royals, but I’ll sure take credit when I can. I remember Dave Nilsson. I once traded Ed Sprague to get Nilsson in a fantasy baseball league about 18 years ago. He was my secret weapon in a solid third-place finish for me that year.
      Glad you’ve decided to go back and read all those posts. Seems like so long ago since I wrote them.
      BTW, please don’t think I’m ignoring you or any of the other readers who often visited my blog over the years. Life has just kind of gotten out of control these days, and I’m hoping to work my way back to the blogging and visiting other blogs sometime soon.
      Thanks for keeping in touch. It’s much appreciated.

  2. Great pick on “Tailwind” Tommy, whom I saw play during his brief stay with the Cleveland Indians in ’68. I didn’t realize he was the first 30-30 man. That’s a remarkable accomplishment, one that changed the way ballplayers are judged by fans and by history.

    Incidentally, Harper went to Encinal High School in Alameda, Calif., home of Willie Stargell Field, named in honor of one of Harper’s teammates. Another Encinal graduate: Jimmy Rollins of the Philadelphia Phillies.

    • Hi, Thanks for the info regarding the baseball players from Encinal H.S. California used to be a powerhouse for sports talent. “Tailwind” Tommy? Never heard that one. He was a few years before my time, actually, so I have no actual memory of him playing. Thanks for checking in and leaving the comment. Regards, Bill

  3. Ken Pryor on said:

    Another great post, Bill! I always enjoy the Best Forgotten Seasons posts. Keep up the great work!

    • Hi Ken, I appreciate your loyalty in following my blog. This series is about to come to and end with my next post on the Angels. It’s gone on long enough, I think. Looking forward to focusing on something else for a change. Thanks again for your kind words, Bill

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: