The On Deck Circle

Baseball History, Commentary and Analysis

Best Forgotten Seasons: Part 11 – The Cleveland Indians

Several professional pundits, as well a few proletarian bloggers,  have designated 2010 as The Year of the Pitcher.

After the homer-happy ’90’s, and even well into this decade, it is as if we have just emerged from a steroid-induced mass hallucination, where real-life Paul Bunyons swung bats the size of small trees, and pitchers, raised from birth in the shadow of aluminum bats and small ballparks, cowered in fear.

But, as the saying goes, everything is relative.  Certainly, pitching has reemerged as a significant force in Major League Baseball.  The depth and breadth of the current crop of young hurlers is stunning.  But obviously, this is not the first time pitching has dominated and defined our National Pastime.

The Gold Standard by which any subsequent Year of the Pitcher is measured is, of course, the 1968 season.

In 1968, the pitcher’s mound was as high as a small mountain, hitters were, on average, smaller than they are today, and pitchers could throw inside with impunity.

In 1968, the combined ERA of the entirety of Major League Baseball was 2.98.  Seven pitchers recorded ERA’s under 2.00.  Five of these pitchers were in the American League.

Over in the N.L., Bob Gibson of the Cardinals set a record for the lowest ERA in a season at 1.12.

Don Drysdale of the Dodgers, who did not have an ERA below 2.00 for the season, broke Walter Johnson’s 55-year old record for consecutive shut-out innings pitched with 58 (later eclipsed by another Dodger, Orel Hershiser.)

Of the five A.L. pitchers who recorded ERA’s below 2.00 in 1968, two pitched for one team, the Cleveland Indians.

Sam McDowell, a fearsome strikeout pitcher who at one point struck out 40 batters over a three game stretch, posted the second best ERA in the A.L., and the second best ERA on his staff, at 1.81.

So who recorded the lowest ERA in the A.L. in 1968?

A 27-year old, cigar smoking Cuban, whose father had pitched against barn-storming Major League and Negro League players in pre-Castro Cuba, Luis Tiant.

In 1959, when Luis Tiant was just nineteen-years old, Fidel Castro came to power in Cuba.  In 1961, Tiant came to America to become a Major League pitcher.  He planned on returning to Cuba the following year to see his family.  But the political situation in Cuba had worsened, and his father warned him not to come home, at least for a while.

Tiant’s exile lasted 46 years.

In 1964, Tiant made his Major League debut.  A decade later, his parents were finally allowed to come to America to see their son pitch.

1968 was Cleveland Indians’ pitcher Luis Tiant’s Best Forgotten Season.

The 1968 season was El Tiante’s fifth in the Major Leagues.  Previously, he had never won more than 12 games in a season.  But in ’68, Tiant’s talent and experience came together to produce a record of 21-9, a league-leading 1.60 ERA, 19 complete games, and a league-leading nine shutouts.

Tiant also surrendered an amazingly low 152 hits in 258 innings pitched.  His 5.3 hits per nine innings not only led the league, it is the second lowest mark ever recorded in Major League history.

Tiant also struck out 264 batters (third most in the league), against just 73 walks.  His ERA+ was a league best 186, and his WHIP was an astoundingly low 0.871.

So how does a pitcher with numbers like these not win the Cy Young Award?

Because he just happens to be pitching in the same league as Denny McLain.  McLain won 31 games against just six losses, posted an ERA of 1.96, and led the A.L. in starts (41), complete games (28!), and innings pitched (336.)

McLain not only won the Cy Young award, he was named A.L. MVP as well.

In other words, Tiant’s season, as great as it was, was just one of several outstanding pitching performances that season.

Later, of course, Tiant would enjoy great success pitching for the Boston Red Sox in the 1970’s, (1971-78.)  In fact, he would post yet another sub-2.00 ERA for the Sox in 1972, (1.91.)

El Tiante tallied three 20-win seasons for the Red Sox, and compiled a record of 122-81 while pitching for them.  In the 1975 World Series, he beat the Big Red Machine twice, his herky-jerky delivery, never quite facing home-plate, instantly making him a hero to a young generation of new baseball fans.

Most baseball fans remember Tiant’s Boston years.  But Tiant probably enjoyed his Best Forgotten Season in 1968 while pitching for the Cleveland Indians.

Should Luis Tiant be in the Hall of Fame?

His career win-loss record is 229-172 with a career ERA of  3.30.  According to, three of the six pitchers whose careers most resembled Tiant’s are in the Hall, including Catfish Hunter, Jim Bunning, and Don Drysdale.

If Tiant ever does get elected to the Hall of Fame, however, a case can certainly be made that his plaque should prominently display him wearing a cap with the Cleveland Indians logo prominently displayed on his head.

Meanwhile, Luis Tiant was finally allowed to return to Cuba in 2007 after an exile that lasted nearly half a century.  Now almost 70 years old, Tiant has come full circle.

The personal sacrifices he made to pursue his dream are beyond the comprehension of most Americans.  But his accomplishments while pitching in America demonstrate the tenacity of his spirit, and the triumph of his soul.

Single Post Navigation

8 thoughts on “Best Forgotten Seasons: Part 11 – The Cleveland Indians

  1. I saw Tiant toss a one-hitter against, I think, the Red Sox one time. It was probably in ’68. He was awesome.

    • Hi, I was always a Tiant fan as well. I think he is a near-miss for the Hall of Fame, but certainly he was an underrated pitcher, and a lot of fun to watch. Thanks for reading, Bill

  2. The Big Red One on said:

    Tiant was a good one. A little known fact about Tiant is that everytime he flushed the toilet after taking a massive dump he would yell “bye Tommy!” in reference to his friend and teammateTommy Harper. He did this every single time. The man was a cutup in the clubhouse. I do not think he belongs in the Hall of Fame as I do not think Drysdale and Bunning belong. Catfish is borderline.

    • Chris, my friend, only you could come up with an anecdote like that. It sure does flesh out the man, though. Personally, I agree with you regarding the Hall of Fame. All of those pitchers are questionable inductees. I think Tiant is close, but no cigar (pun intended.) Thanks for checking in, Bill.

  3. I enjoyed the Luis Tiant info. Many current baseball fans do not pay enough attention to the history of the game. It is so easy to be “wowed” by today’s talent as every game is available for instant download.

    Some people are just fans of a particular team and do not appreciate other players. Baseball history is what makes this game so much fun.

    Great job!

    • Hi Jacqueline, I agree with you. Baseball history is to me the main reason why I love baseball. Of course, I follow the game today, too. But it’s not just many of the fans who don’t know the history of the game. Even many players have little or no knowledge of baseball’s traditions. Guess that’s why myself and others (like Verdun2) write these blog posts.
      As always, thanks for reading, and for leaving the comment. I look forward to your next post as well. Bill

  4. Ken Pryor on said:

    Not much to add here, just wanted to say thanks for another great article. I didn’t follow baseball as a kid, so I hadn’t heard of Luis Tiant till now. Sounds like he certainly belongs in the Hall.

    • Hi Ken, It’s good to hear from you. I haven’t been on Twitter all that much this summer, but I’m glad you’re still following me. I remember Tiant as a kid when he was pitching in the ’75 World Series against the Reds. I don’t go back much further than that in terms of my personal memories about baseball. Glad my blog-post was useful. Always appreciate hearing from you. Thanks for reading, Bill

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: